Re: [Harp-L] explain positions to beginner

[Michael Taylor <mjmt.taylor@xxxxxxxxx>]

I didn't really get the idea of positions until I was playing with a paddy
richter D harp. I realised I could do what I call the "standard" middle
eastern tune, suddenly easily accessed by 3 blow. It sounded entirely
different. I furthered with first, second, and third position using my
ukulele to play 'Saints go Marching In' in a minor v major scale,
afterwards trying the same tune in first, second, and third and listening
to the difference. Suddenly the idea became obvious, though I don't always
have the ability to play it routinely myself.

MFG,
Mike


On 24 June 2014 20:47, <jrumbaug@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:

> Every position has advantages and disadvantages. I can not give you a
> single sentence that can be read to convey the difference, unless it was
> the first line I wrote. :)
>
> I say there is one example where he can hear the differences, assuming you
> know how to wail in second position.  In second position on a C harp start
> with 2 draw and play root, 3rd, 4th , 5th, and wail on the 5th, ., maybe
> add a little dirty note blend. Then take a G harp and do the same notes
> starting on the 4 blow.  If he does not hear the difference, let him
> continue to play melodies in 1st position until heâs ready to move on.
>
> Jim Rumbaugh
>