[Harp-L] chromatic lip blocking tension problem
- To: harp-l@xxxxxxxxxx
- Subject: [Harp-L] chromatic lip blocking tension problem
- From: Boris Plotnikov <ploboris@xxxxxxxxx>
- Date: Wed, 27 Nov 2013 01:41:19 +0400
- Dkim-signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=gmail.com; s=20120113; h=mime-version:date:message-id:subject:from:to:content-type; bh=qDs/BP74HJWs0T6SMdvqgcgFG5ncQSOJQhSdeHuurgY=; b=nlVs5OAwTl8mY2mDNXuUaG7yhKgsmwD8uKhUzXQlVIce6Cgj8hRun7WbNhHbuwND62 OzuM+ScLOEWr9700BzgzJTixwN+7MAbX9idVLaIk4RkWlY9Em1BnjqN8AxF0bQ8DAiaC WZ+j6+qj2RmS0rbUvGSCz7q53Cn/7t4iqPOJWMu8v2TSW1i6w3TTquOkBLtUgaculhg8 KauhGp/qEIV/iLTfvq0zrg9s1cLfjVjYt9GZXPTNnHxgWjgmnWgne9grNeSKn6k6kBc/ bBb4Uy32w6Gr/EqQlhpY13qc8oDSeoL39SS/pgXLZP3YtGwpCyRmPGgISypxqpwPlrbf xT/g==
I started diatonic with U-blocking (first year or so, about 12 years ago),
then after being unsatisfied with my lip blocking I went to almost 100%
tongue blocking for 5 years or so. Then I discovered overbends and needed a
lip block and found tilted harmonica position for diatonic which gave me
100% relaxed lip position. Now I play diatonic 80% lip blocking, 20% tongue
blocking. For lip blocking my upper lip covers about 2/3 of 1847
coverplate, my bottom lip covers only 1/4 or even less of bottom
coverplate, so back part of my harp is tilted up about 30-40 degrees. I
think for diatonic it's a perfect relaxed position and it works for me and
for 90% of my students better than other ways, I had one student which
could block single hole only with harmonica tilted down (opposite) and 2 or
3 students from another teacher who are used to hold harmonica straight.
Also while playing 100% tongue blocked I learned a chromatic and played it
a lot for some years. After I discovered overbends I almost gave up playing
chromatic (also I wasn't happy with instruments, no spare reeds etc). Now I
get two perfect Saxonies (Orchestra and regular C) and set of spare reeds
and I found that I like to play some tunes on chromatic just for different
tone, phrasing and expression. But I have the problem.
I'm absolutely happy with playing chromatic tongue blocking (except I need
to practice more scales, tunes and other layout excercises). As you
possible notice I'm a big fan of double ("taka") and tripple staccatto
("tkta") and it's important part of my style and I wish to use it on
chromatic too, but it doesn't work good with tongue blocking. I definetely
need a lip blocking on a chromatic. Than ooops. It doesn't work to tilt
chromatic, because of mouthpiece, I have leakage between lips and
coverplate. Keeping harmonica straight don't allow me to relax lips, I feel
some unpleasant tension, I hear it affects my tone and my lips get tired.
Any ideas how to hold chromatic in a mouth with 100% relaxed lips?
--
Thanks, Boris Plotnikov
http://borisplotnikov.ru
This archive was generated by a fusion of
Pipermail 0.09 (Mailman edition) and
MHonArc 2.6.8.