Re: [Harp-L] manji quality ??

[Grant Walters <grant@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

David:
My heart goes out to you...and I can see why you might be disappointed ...
however...
> Within the next year or two, with our current govt's "backward, non-business friendly, pro recession, pro inflation "  type way of doing things, you can be sure that the prices for these terrible sounding stock harps will rise at least another 25 to 50%. 
> Not to mention the extremely low pay that all gigging Blues musicians are getting paid these days. Most Blues musicians was making more money per gig 20 years ago and things cost half as much!
Dude...you are bumming me out.....This is not a harmonica issue...
I play harp to get away from my this kind of negative space....
Maybe you can sit down and write a good song about this...

or spend the money on the Harmonica repair.../ adjustment kits...videos...etc...
I personally am looking forward to a hands on class one day as there never seems to be enough time...
I did buy the Richard Sleigh kit but it does not come with instant knowledge...unfortunately...still I love having it.
If i sit and think about the price of gas ...I won't even want to drive to the gig...
If someone will pay me to play harmonica....I have already won the day...
Might I suggest, as others have, packaging a duo...if money is the object...downsize... worked for me.

I don't know Mr. Manji but after meeting Brendan Power, I can say, he is very well represented...and while I don't play suzuki's ...my experience with them has been pretty darn good.

"20 years ago"...I did not even know what an overblow was..

Hope you do get a fair resolution here...as no body wants to waste money...
You deserve better ...but in the meantime...hope things go better for you .....

Grant Walters...





On May 22, 2011, at 9:15 AM, david robbins wrote:

> Well, I finally tried a manji. I have come to the conclusion that Mr Manji put his name on that harp just for marketing purposes and to make money. It's not that he feels so strongly about it being a fantastic harp. That's just pure bunk. It's not bad, but certainly no better than stock LO's,MB's, or GM's. It's just a matter of taste.
>  I think it's very unfortunate and an embarrassment, that the public can't get a "ready to gig" quality stock, outta the box instrument for 35-45 dollars. 
>  Unless you are really good at working on your own harps, you are going to have to spend even more money paying someone to make an already overpriced harmonica play at its full capability. Or you can send the harp back to the manufacturer, and if are really lucky, you'll get it back in a playable state.
> I have not tried a seydel yet, so I may hesitantly try one. 
> Within the next year or two, with our current govt's "backward, non-business friendly, pro recession, pro inflation "  type way of doing things, you can be sure that the prices for these terrible sounding stock harps will rise at least another 25 to 50%. 
> Not to mention the extremely low pay that all gigging Blues musicians are getting paid these days. Most Blues musicians was making more money per gig 20 years ago and things cost half as much!
> 
>