[Harp-L] Gus the harmonica player

["John F. Potts" <hvyj@xxxxxxx>]

In any field of endeavor, the inept or inexperienced often don't  
realize what they don't know.  Because a harmonica doesn't have keys  
or frets (or a mouthpiece that won't let you play a note without  
using proper embouchure), once a person can get a single note, bend  
some holes and understands what harp to use in order to play in  
second position, they are tempted to think they can play.  And since  
it's actually hard to hit a really bad note playing major key blues  
in second position, they are able to delude themselves.  
Unfortunately, many such players are also resistant to learning some  
practical music theory when given the opportunity. But they are  
usually not shy about taking whatever opportunities that may present  
themselves to jam or play with other musicians in public, because it  
can be exhilarating. And when exhilarated, it's easy to get carried  
away. This is a combination of characteristics that combine to give  
harmonica players in general a bad reputation.

It's one thing not to know what you don't know. That is often a  
starting point, and we all have to start somewhere. The problem is  
with those who remain oblivious to what they don't know and so never  
develop musically on the instrument.  And there is no lack of non- 
musicians who think they can play the harmonica.

Lest i appear to be too judgmental, I am self taught and play no  
other instrument.  But, over the years, I've learned a lot from the  
musicians I've played with, and the more i learn, the more i  
understand what there is that I don't know.  And one of the most  
important things to know is when to lay out.

JP