Hi Richard -
Richard Hammersley wrote:
There are certainly quite a few computer-based systems that will
convert tones to MIDI, from voice etc.
Can you name a piece of software that will do this in real time with
reasonably low latency and do it well? I'd like to try it. I'm not
looking for something that sort of works. I'm looking for something that
does this particular task extremely well.
But why use MIDI rather than working with the digitized acoustic
signal itself?
Because MIDI is the standard way to control almost any synthesizer. I
would like to layer a synthesizer on top of the harmonica. Perhaps a
Prophet '08 (http://www.davesmithinstruments.com/products/p8/)...
In my view, MIDI is being supplanted by real time processing of the
acoustic wave form, which gives greater flexibility. Nowadays this
processing can occur in real time.
I think we're talking apples vs. oranges here. You're not going to find
a processor that can add (for example) the sound of a cello to a
harmonica sound, but with MIDI, that's a no-brainer.
It used to be that computers tended to be fragile for live performance
but modern laptops are tougher
...
Sure. And I used to use a computer live on my 6 nights per week lounge
gigs when they _were_ quite fragile. However, even today, they are not
quite as convenient to set up as a simple stomp box ;-).
For instance John McLaughlin live uses an Apple power book in
preference to an effects rack. He doesn't always use a guitar to midi
converter, but also processes the acoustic signal in the computer,
including synth sounds.
http://www.johnmclaughlin.com/
If the internal software is tracking his guitar and triggering a synth,
then it is most likely using MIDI internally to route the performance
information to the soft synth, in which case we're really talking about
the same thing (pitch-to-MIDI), just without the MIDI cable.
Given that McLaughlin not only delivers a very high (and varied)
standard of sound and plays extraordinarily fast, a set-up like his
would probably work for anyone. It seems to be made entirely of
industry-standard bits of software and hardware.
Guitar synth pickups are common, but the pitch-to-MIDI conversion that
happens in hardware or software for a guitar synth is not, to my
knowledge, available for use with a microphone or line input -- with a
few exceptions. I have an old Axon guitar synth controller that does
have a line input. And it works terribly -- it is unusable -- so bad
that they no longer include it on their more recent controllers.
My point is that the technology exists, but does not seem to be
available for use outside of the guitar synth world.
...
Richard
- Slim
www.slidemanslim.com
_______________________________________________
Harp-L is sponsored by SPAH, http://www.spah.org
Harp-L@xxxxxxxxxx
http://harp-l.org/mailman/listinfo/harp-l