[Harp-L] weighted abs combs
 
Brendan Power wrote:
> The especially cool thing with them is that Suzuki is using a
> patent-pending innovation for adding tone and response to the humble
> injection-moulded ABS comb. They add brass weights to the rear and sides
> of the comb, which gives more heft to the comb and greater inertia 
for the
> reeds to swing against.
>
> Yes Vern, it DOES make a difference to the sound!
i'm having a little trouble imagining how this can work.  the mass of 
the comb
is already pretty high, relative to that of the reeds.  and when you're 
holding
the harp you effectively add your own mass to that of the comb, which would
far outweigh any effect the weights might have.  if the weights work by 
increasing
the mass of the comb, then you'd expect that combs made of any material 
denser
then abs plastic would show similar differences.  but this has not been 
demonstrated,
to my knowledge, in the (admittedly limited) public testing.
so what am i missing?
     
     This archive was generated by a fusion of 
     Pipermail 0.09 (Mailman edition) and 
     MHonArc 2.6.8.