Message: 12
Date: Sat, 17 May 2008 08:10:16 -0400
From: Robert Bonfiglio <BON@xxxxxxxxxx>
Subject: Re: [Harp-L] U-blocking
To: "john" <jjthaden@xxxxxxxxx>
Cc: dennis moriarty <dmoriarty@xxxxxxxxxx>, harp-l@xxxxxxxxxx
Message-ID: <AD4BBA77-7B30-43E4-AB05-0AF0560172F2@xxxxxxxxxx>
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=US-ASCII; delsp=yes; format=flowed
Dear John,
I actually said I use u-block and sometimes whistle position for the
center part of a left-center-right switch and also to play all three
notes at the same time, i.e., A-D-A which is the octave with the
forth in the center. The u then covers the B and the F. I use that
center corner switch in the Tcherepnin Harmonica Concerto to play
legato from left to center to right.
The U-Block does color the sound making it difficult to get the deep
sound of the corner, my sound, or the round sound of the center,
Toots' sound, but I find playing the pinched sound, Stevie's sound,
easier in U-Block.
My point about U-Block is that as a main embouchure it takes away the
tongue switching and the use of tongue articulation that you get from
tongue block and whistle respectively. It makes certain things,
especially for the student, harder to do and my whole way of playing
the harmonica is take the easiest route and spend more time making
music and less time on technique.
Start a student in tongue block or whistle and the road is easier On
diatonic I find the highest notes easier to play on the right in
tongue block, but I mainly use whistle. On the chromatic, I am
finding more and more use of the left side on low notes.
I remember once at Toots' apartment in New York playing "When Sunny
Gets Blue" and using a corner switch. He said, "Your'e switching
corners" and I said yes. He said "I don't do that." But just
imagine if he did!!!
Harmonically yours,
Robert Bonfiglio
http://www.robertbonfiglio.com
On May 17, 2008, at 2:14 AM, john wrote:
Larry and Dennis,
I'm a u-blocker too. U-blocking has been discussed a lot in
the past (see archives) and I've chimed in then as well. From
those exchanges, I learned that there are a few u-blockers who play
with a real tongue-curl, and in at least one case, with the curl
very tight, just like a straw, but as you both point out, not all
do, and neither do I. There is a misconception that, if a person
can't curl their tongue, then they can't u-block; this is just
plain wrong. A student I taught coudn't curl, but picked up u-
blocking easily from me and really ran with it. But, as do I, he
also uses regular tongue-blocking (out of both the left and right)
and lip-blocking. I'm probably about 80% u-blocking.
I have a slightly different way of describing what happens
with my tongue. The way I think of it, because the tip is on the
mouthpiece (or even the cover plate) below the played hole(s), the
tongue simply can't block those holes, if the tongue is then
pressed forward gently, it mashes up against the remaining holes,
forming a relaxed U shape. Some u-blockers tip the harp down into
the U (as many lip-blockers do into their lower lip); I don't, and
I think the reason why is that my embouchure is pretty deep and I'd
have to open my jaw wider (teeth further apart) to accomodate a
tipped harp.
As Larry points out, u-blockers can experience some
criticism. In past discussions, this has included strong advice
against u-blocking from at least one professional player and
teacher, the confirmed tongue-blocker/corner-switcher/spit-
articulator Robert Bonfiglio. Paraphrasing as best I recall,
Robert felt u-blocking was inferior and unnecessary. I argued that
it provides a "third corner" (the center), without having to pull
the harp partway out of the mouth (as for lip-blocking), but he
didn't buy that. Works for me, anyway.
Speaking of articulation, I'd be interested to know you the
two of you do it, e.g., produce a string of notes of the same
pitch. I use a modified "t", but made by making contact with the
upper palate (edge between hard and soft) using a part of the
tongue well back from the tip (The tip obviously is otherwise
occupied.). It's pretty fast, and (unlike some consonants used
during lip-pursing, but much like a tongue-blocker's side-of-tongue-
with-cheek articulation) it doesn't do wild things with the timbre
of the note (e.g., ugly wah-like effects).
Dennis, I agree with you that a real strength of u-blocking
is how incredibly strong and controllable long notes are,
particularly, the pitch of bent notes. Bending is so darned
precise, I think exactly because it does ~not~ involve tongue
movements. Larry, I have a different conception of how bends and
overblows happen than your description of changes in the angle of
the airflow, a conception solidified when I read 10 years ago the
description of the harmonica-playing interface developed by Drs.
Bahnson, Antaki and Beery (www.andrew.cmu.edu/user/antaki/articles/
Bahnson%20JASA%201998.pdf). Their device changes the ratio of the
chamber volume directly behind the reed (in a human player, the
mouth and upper throat cavities) to the area of the constriction
behind that chamber (in a human player, formed at any of several
points, understandable by thinking about the stop consonants "g"
and "k", the Germanic "ch" as in "achtung", throat clearing, and
gargling). But I do !
agree that this ratio can be controlled quite nicely with u-
blocking. There are exceptions: on really low harps (say from a
low D down to a double-low F), I can bend deeper using lip-pursing
than either tongue-block embouchure; I can overblow better while
lip-pursing; and some "talked" rhythms work better lip-pursing. I
use regular tongue blocking for all non-adjacent double-stops
(except when I need to block just one hole, where I use a hybrid
tongue/U-block); for a lot of corner-switching, and for some tongue-
slap effects, though u-blocking is great too for percussive tonguing.
Dennis, you asked Larry for recordings or a web page. I'd
like to hear that too. FYI, I can be heard on harp and vocals at
http://mikedollins.biz on a CD entitled "Live, Love Laugh". I had
to lay the harp tracks onto bass and drums with no scratch vocals
or anything else, which is rather crippling for a guy used to
trying to make singers sound good live, plus, there are some weird
synchrony issues with the harp track on at least one cut, but you
can pretty much hear what I do. You'll see I'm a good bit behind
the times, technically, and am working hard to catch up (thanks
Jason Ricci for your Youtube stuff!). I too have wondered if I'm
slowed somewhat by u-blocking vs. puckering, but it's too early in
my renewed woodshedding phase to tell.