[Harp-L] Re: Searching for Half-Valved Players
Dare I ask where you place the XB40 in all this?
>>> "Brendan Power" <bren@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> 13/06/2007 20:16:09 >>>
--- Larry Marks < <mailto:larry.marks%40barberry.com>
> Fellow harmonica types,
>I just recently heard of both SPAH and this list. I have been lurking
> for a while and searching the archives, but have found little on
> (half-) valved diatonics, which I like to play. I am hoping to find
> who are similarly inclined.
Good to hear of players taking the half-valved harmonica seriously.
a long-term acolyte: I started half-valving my diatonics in the mid
80's, and soon after did the same with chromatics; all my recordings
on half-valved harps, diatonics and chromatics. Suzuki's ProMaster
MR350-V, the first commercial half-valved diatonic, was a result of my
suggesting the idea to Suzuki.
After getting used to the beautiful expressiveness of the half-valved
diatonic, it is very hard to go back to playing an un-valved harp. The
lower 7 blow notes and upper 4 draws can be given vibrato and bending
effects, which I really miss on an un-valved harp. However, using a
half-valved diatonic for fully chromatic playing is another kettle of
fish. On a diatonic, I use half-valving for expression, not
chromaticism. Getting the bend down to pitch is not too bad, but
a valved bend in tune, stable and sounding nice is very hard, and for
the results are too nasty to be practically usable. Knowing how hard
is, I appreciate the efforts of those who try this route - especially
Gazell. It would be interesting to hear your experiences of using
However, I feel there is a better way to go: the half-valved
Chromatics need to be intrinsically very airtight and preferably in
alternate tunings (where every blow and draw reed is at least a tone
apart) to really suit half-valving. But when it's set up right, in my
opinion the half-valved chromatic is the best all-round harp in terms
combining expressiveness and real usable chromaticism.
Even on a Solo-tuned chromatic you can half-valve every odd-numbered
hole (1,3,5,7,9,11) to get semitone draw bends, though it's best to
leave draw valves on holes 4 and 8, and on hole 2 and perhaps 6. For
those familiar with Richter tuning, Hohner's half-valved Slide Harp is
available, though it is sadly not nearly as airtight as it should be.
With customisation it works a lot better, and better half-valved
chroms can be made using the larger holes of the cross-style slider.
Diminished and Whole-Tone tuning are great on half-valved chromatic,
you get a lot of enharmonics using slide or bent notes, and you can
think up an infinite range of other tunings that would also suit.
Though I love the half-valved chromatic, there are very few serious
players. Apart from the fact there is no good off-the-shelf
chrom available, there are two reasons, I think: Traditional chromatic
players are used to the sound of valves on all holes (many of the old
school wouldn't want to bend notes anyway), and Howard Levy's
work on overblow diatonic has given diatonic players a way to achieve
chromaticism whilst retaining the traditional unvalved diatonic.
Both instruments and approaches have their strengths and appeal, and I
love hearing great players using either approach, but to me the
half-valved chromatic gives the best of both worlds: all chromatic
easy to obtain and in tune, as well as diatonic-type bending on half
notes, giving many enharmonics (and therefore alternate phrasing
options), and lots of expression.
WEB: http://www.brendan-power.com <http://www.brendan-power.com/>
Harp-L is sponsored by SPAH, http://www.spah.org
This archive was generated by a fusion of
Pipermail 0.09 (Mailman edition) and