[Harp-L] Separating the chaff




For years we have been seeing this contest and that contest (ad nauseum) for harmonica players, blues, jazz, country, blue grass.
Why not a contest for the manufacturers? Didn't we once HAVE that? I mean, why not a Grand Prix for the manufacturers cup? Weren't there medallions pressed into the covers of Hohners, Seydels and a myriad of other European harmonicas at one time. Vienna, Berlin, Paris, Cleveland? What?...... we're supposed to let them all rest on their proverbial laurels?


Here's my plan. First of all there are too many harmonicas. Well, let me re-phrase. Too many models. Putting the spotlight only on diatonics and chromos (for now), this is my breakdown. Prices are arbitrary, and only used as a guide to show relativity.

1.... diatonic..... 0-$8.49 (beginner, gift, or stocking stuffer)
2.... diatonic.....$8.50-$28.49 (intermediate, student, learner, serious)
3.... diatonic.....$28.50-$95.49 (professional, custom, tweaked, special, studio)
4.... diatonic.....above $95.50


1.... chromo.....0-$63.99 (beginner, gift, prize)
2.... chromo.....$64.oo-$215.oo (intermediate, student, learner, serious)
3.... chromo.....$215.oo-$725.oo (professional, concert)
4.... chromo.....above $725.oo


Just like in the car, motorcycle, boat, snowmobile, waverunner, RV, travel trailer world, a group of 100 harmonica players are assembled and test these harmonicas in these CLASSES.

Qualification(s)... player must have been heard of by 1000 people...ANY people
Loose qualif........ player cannot be an endorser of any existing brand...(conflict of interest)


The testers receive the harps to test. You don't want to submit harps. Fine, don't bother trying to sell any. You don't want to compete. Fine, shut your doors, and start making disposable pens. You want to keep making junk. Fine, go into the scrap metal business.

The problem right now (as 'I' see it) is that by the time you try every harp, it took you 53.6 years and $12,413.50. See, THAT's what they want. That's what they want. If they can sell everyone just ONE harp or several gajillion people a couple harps, they have their money. And what do YOU have? You have what I have been reading here for 10 1/2 years. "Hey, I got this (insert harp name) and the #4 draw..yada yada yada", or "They can put a man on the moon, so why can't I get the 6-7 draw bend in 9th position to yada yada".

Naah, we need an international competition for MANUFACTURERS. Now let's see, what bank should I use to set up the 'super-fund'?

smokey-joe's bizare world






This archive was generated by a fusion of Pipermail 0.09 (Mailman edition) and MHonArc 2.6.8.