[Harp-L] rosewood

[Jonathan Ross <jross38@xxxxxxxxxxx>]

As I have actually mentioned on this list several times before, yes  
rosewood is potentially toxic.  Some people will get contact  
reactions to it, others allergies.  I doubt there is much of a way to  
predict this, except that if you are somewhat prone to allergies and  
asthma, it might be best to simply not even try an instrument with a  
rosewood comb.

While rosewood probably wouldn't be my first choice for a comb  
material, the likelihood of reaction is fairly small for any given  
person.  Personally, I'd not use wood if I had the ability (as Suzuki  
does) of using precision injection-molded plastic combs.  But, then,  
people would be complaining about the price because it's "just a  
plastic comb", not to mention the "warmth" of wood argument and all  
that.

Let's not overstate the dangers here.  They do exist and are real,  
but for most people using rosewood combs and covers (sealed ones  
especially) will be perfectly safe.  The best thing is to be informed  
and aware of the risks (and, as I said to begin with--I've pointed  
them out before).  When I purchase one of these harps, I will be sure  
to watch out for signs of a reaction in the first week or so.  If  
there is none, the likelihood is that there won't be one.  Let's not  
panic over this the way people panic over lead.

Actually, having already played rosewood covered harps before, I am  
pretty sure that I will not react.  However, I will also be aware of  
possible warning signs.



 ()()    JR "Bulldogge" Ross
()  ()   & Snuffy, too:)
`----'