Re: [Harp-L] Re:10 year old student

["Dave Murray" <dlmurray@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

From: <MilwHarmonica@xxxxxxx>
> Dave's suggestion is an excellent one for a young student, if the student
> wants to learn a few songs. But if the student wants to learn to play the
> harmonica, I wouldn't recommend limiting the student's study to the rote 
> system
> (ear training and memory only). Memory isn't always accurate. Use all the
> senses, including sight (traditional notation) and touch.


Without a doubt, if he really wants to learn, give him the whole deal. I 
wasn't suggesting shortchanging his studies. I was basing it on the idea 
that this was a ten year old who asked "Will you teach me to play the 
harmonica?" At that age showing him how to find a tune will work with his 
natural curiosity, and in this day and age he probably expects near instant 
gratification. Once he sees/hears that he can make real music on the harp he 
should be encouraged to learn more. There is lots of excellent educational 
stuff (books/cds/dvds) and I've got some. I don't undervalue it, the ten 
year old boy factor influenced my opinion greatly.

Peace and music,
Dave