[Harp-L] Rob P's Me and Bobby McGee (kinda long)
Hopefully Rob Paparozzi will chime in on this.
I saw Rob play with Dolly twice this past week. Both times i had vcr
snafu's - the first time on the Conan Show i only taped the first 30 seconds and
missed the rest, including the key change. The second time on The View show,
i saw the last half of the song and totally missed taping it .
On the Conan Show, the song started in Bb, then modulated. Did it
modulate a whole step to C with Rob switching from an Eb harp to an F harp?
I missed half of the song on The View, so when i tuned in was already past
the modulation part of the song. At the end of the song, when i grabbed my
guitar to see what key it was in, i got Bb. Did they not modulate or did
they start the song in Ab? At the end of the song, Dolly apologised for messing
up. What happened?
My all-time fav. rendition is Charlie McCoy's instrumental version on his
2nd or 3rd album, entitled "Charlie McCoy". I havent heard the orig.
Kristoferson version (with Charlie on harp, i believe), in many many years but
here's something i do, which i may have gotten from the orig. version.
Example: Acc. to a sound clip i found on the net, the orig. version
starts in key of A. If u want to play in second position, use a D harp; then an E
harp when and if the song modulates a whole step.
In the orig. version, iirc, the harp first appears after the word "blues,
as in: "I was blowin' sad while Bobbie sang the blues". At the word "blues"
the chord moves to the IV chord (to a D chord). At the word "blues", have
your high G harp in hand and use draw holes 3, 4, 3, 3 bend, and 2 to do a
nice accenting 5 note riff in D. Then get rid of the G harp and start using
your D harp if u want to accompany some more in 2nd position before the song
modulates.
Back in the old days before high G's were manufactured, Charlie would have
used a Hohner Vest Pocket key of G harp, which is/was tuned an octave higher
than a normal G harp. As we know, nowadays they make regular sized
diatonics tuned to high G.
On the Conan Show, Rob started the song playing in Bb using an Eb harp.
To do the 5 note accent riff on the IV chord, Rob would have had to grab an
Ab harp (preferably a high Ab, if they make 'em).
ron
This archive was generated by a fusion of
Pipermail 0.09 (Mailman edition) and
MHonArc 2.6.8.