RE: [Harp-L] Re: C in 12 poitions

["Laurent" <laurent@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

Hey Robert,

Big thanks for your explanation! I definitely was wrong and badly understood what Mox wrote!
Now I understand and would like to thank Mox for this interesting remark.

All the best to all

    Laurent

----- Message d'origine -----
   >De: "Robert Coble"<bobcoble@xxxxxxx>
   >Env: 03/05/05 20:36:34
   >À: "harp-l@xxxxxxxxxx"<harp-l@xxxxxxxxxx>
   >Objet: [Harp-L] Re: C in 12 poitions
   >
   > > From: Mox Gowland <mox.gowland@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>:
   > >
   > > Follow the circle of 4th's
   > >
   > > MUSIC KEY in "C" -
   > >
   > > Position -  [KEY OF] Harmonica   - Tonic [NOTE]
   > >     1)                  "C"                                  1 BLOW
  .....
   > > Mox
   >
   >My emphasis (and spelling change) added above.
   >
   >Somebody is NOT paying attention to what Mox wrote.
   >
   >He stipulated that the KEY of the music is "C". That is
   >a constant throughout the rest of the info.
   >
   >Consequently, you can find the correct KEY OF HARP
   >A-N-D the correct "position" (in the traditional sense) to
   >play the MUSIC KEY of "C" by following the Circle of
   >Fourths (counterclockwise around the Circle of Fifths).
   >
   >Extracting some examples from above:
   >
   >If you are playing on an "F" harp in 2nd position, then
   >the MUSIC KEY is "C".
   >
   >If you are playing a "Bb" harp in 3rd position, then
   >the MUSIC KEY is "C".
   >
   >If you are playing a "G" harp in 12th position, then
   >the MUSIC KEY is "C".
   >
   >Please read it again CAREFULLY!
   >
   >I am NOT going to get into another discussion of "modes"!
   >
   >I'll go back to lurkin' and larnin' now by layin' out for
   >the next chorus...
   >
   >Crazy (about harp) Bob
   >