Re: [Harp-L] Favorite Brand/Model of Diatonic?

[tom ball <havaball@xxxxxxx>]

> CHARLES BASSI wrote:
>
> Aside from using altered tunings, which may be available in one brand/model
> and not another of diatonic, do you harpers find it best to stick to 
> one brand/model of harmonica?
> =============


Just speaking for myself, but I do indeed find it best to stick with one brand.

Maybe I'm losing my marbles, but to me the Oskars sound slightly 
sharper in pitch than the Hohners.  Granted, both of the brands are 
tuned slightly sharp to pitch, which is why Kenny and I always tune 
by ear and never use tuners. I'm only guessing here -- I've never 
calibrated this -- but the Oskars sound about A=443 or A=444, whereas 
the Hohners sound about A=442.  Has anyone ever calibrated this 
phenomenon using meters?  I'd like to know if I'm nuts... <g>

This doesn't really create a problem when playing with tuneable 
instruments (guitars etc,) but it can be a significant problem if 
you're playing along with, say, a grand piano.  Many times in a 
studio session I've had to ask the engineer to VSO the harp a few 
cents flatter in order to play in tune with a well-tuned (A=440) 
piano.

My point being, I personally find it difficult to mix Oskars and 
Hohners in the same set of harps -- the Oskars being slightly sharp 
to the Hohners.  Therefore, I'd recommend sticking with whichever of 
the two you like, and use them for every key.  I respect Lee and 
think he makes a fine product, but I happen to prefer the (US 
version) Special 20's for my style.

And I haven't yet tried the Suzukis -- can anybody out there offer 
any input as to how they fit into the picture, tuning-wise?

cheers and best to all,

-Tom Ball
http://www.tomballksennysultan.com