Re: "magic box"

[eben ross <ebenross@xxxxxxxxx>]

ditto   expensive   maybe less so once repair is possable  metal fatuge gets um every time    ben

Martin Oldsberg <martinoldsberg@xxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:The tone of some of the posts in this thread (like the one quoted below) seems to say that it´s "outrageous" IN ITSELF to question the price of the item in question. (And, perhaps, other products as well? Harps? Cf development of Hohner price/quality since the 70s.) The market price is always right; you can always elect not to buy the product. 
Isn´t this a bit stifling in an open forum? The harmonica is somewhat paradoxically one of the most expensive instruments to play (unless you´re satisfied with the single Marine Band, playing acoustic in your own living room), and should it not only be permitted, but encouraged, to ask questions wheter a product is reasonably priced or not?

I know nothing at all about the Harp Commander, but from what I hear on the list it sounds very interesting, and when my ship comes in I might very well be in line for one myself.

Martin

Date: Mon, 03 May 2004 17:12:14 -0400 
From: Ron/datadigr 
Subject: Re: "magic box" 

Hi all: 

I wonder why any folks at all are complaining about the price. 
Why hassle or criticize the one person out there who is actually 
providing the unit when no-one else has really bothered? Bottom 
line is that there is no rip-off even _possible_ with this unit's 
pricing: if you don't think it's worth it, simply refrain from getting 
one or build it yourself. All voluntary, all good. 

My hat's off to Mr. Holmes simply because he didn't just talk about 
making a unit that would help harp players--he actually went ahead and 
did it. Way to go. He deserves and has honestly earned every penny he 
makes. 

And I use a Digitech RP-300, not a Commander. No affiliation, not even 
a customer. 

Ron 

Monday, May 03, 2004, 9:18:11 AM, you wrote: 


SR> Oh, come on! Get real! The HC is almost $300! 
SR> Even "quality components" that are "hand selected" 
SR> are not that expensive. Your response sounds like an advertisement. 

SR> Richard J. Smith, R.A. 
SR> rismith@xxxxxxxxxxx 

- ------------------------------ 



		
- ---------------------------------
Do you Yahoo!?
Win a $20,000 Career Makeover at Yahoo! HotJobs